LoadBehavior = 3 (both decimal and dword)
Edit:
*CORRECTION*
The PC that was having the problem had LoadBehavior = 2. Changed it to 3 (to match mine that is working) and all is working now with one MINOR glitch. I shared a single folder with the user, and they can view EVERYTHING of mine. All my email, contacts, folders, etc. Surely thats not by design.

One caveat though, he is an admin. Does that matter and thus the reason he can view everything I have?