Brought it up because I noticed 5.0.9_GA_2533.SLES10_64_20080815132730 FOSS in your profile.
Timeline:
-Tar formatter was added to 5.0.9
-We released 5.0.10 FOSS
-I wrote that
blog using a build between 5.0.9 > 5.0.10 experiencing no issues.
-A few people discovered that it's very iffy in 5.0.9 with some bugs (that had already been addressed in 5.0.10 FOSS).
-An
additional fix was added to 5.0.10 branch.
The upcoming 5.0.10 NE release next week will contain the above corrections & we also plan to release a new 5.0.10 FOSS at that time, as several NE fixes had open source code changes.
(Personally I have yet to hit trouble with the tar formatter on the 5.0.10 FOSS binaries currently available for download - if your store and database is in good shape it works quite well.)
We also use tar for sync items in a few places now (or are in the process of replacing zip) so it'll be much refined in future releases/we will obviously stay on top of any issues with that format.