Domainkeys Help

[t0kneneng]

Hi! I have some problem with my zimbra mail all send mail when client received is all in spam yahoo, msn, google... etc been reading some post here from the forum and still I have no success trying to setup been following this guide from this url.

Set Up DKIM For Multiple Domains On Postfix With dkim-milter 2.8.x (CentOS 5.3) | HowtoForge - Linux Howtos and Tutorials

Installing DKIM for Zimbra on CentOS or Red Hat | Le blog d'Étienne Pouliot

By they way I have multiple domain. ea. mydomain1.com, mydomain2.com

Everytime I restart zmmtactl the config that I append on master.cf is gone.

[t0kneneng]

Hi when I try to enable milter_protocol = 2

I have this error

May 27 10:53:22 ns2 dkim-filter[22864]: D1B8121E8A5B: no signature data (Also all incoming email is rejected)

When I remove it I have this error

warning: milter inet:localhost:20209: can’t read SMFIC_DATA reply packet header: Success

Please help... maybe someone already encountered this issue?

[phoenix]

Originally Posted by t0kneneng

Everytime I restart zmmtactl the config that I append on master.cf is gone.

You're modifying the wrong file, check the instructions again.

You might find it easier to use dk-milter (take your pick of the instruction) I use that with multiple domains without problems. I will say that the instructions that you've posted links for also work and with multiple domains, I tested them as well before settling on dk-milter.

[t0kneneng]

Originally Posted by phoenix

You're modifying the wrong file, check the instructions again.

You might find it easier to use dk-milter (take your pick of the instruction) I use that with multiple domains without problems. I will say that the instructions that you've posted links for also work and with multiple domains, I tested them as well before settling on dk-milter.

Hi thanks for the response actually at first I did try to change this /opt/zimbra/postfix/conf/master.cf after rrestart zmmtactl all the new config I added all gone.

-o smtpd_milters=inet:localhost:20209
-o milter_default_action=accept
-o disable_mime_output_conversion=yes
-o non_smtpd_milters=inet:localhost:20209

So How I may be able to retain this config after restart?

[phoenix]

Originally Posted by t0kneneng

Hi thanks for the response actually at first I did try to change this /opt/zimbra/postfix/conf/master.cf after rrestart zmmtactl all the new config I added all gone.

I've already said that you're modifying the wrong file, go to the second link you posted and read the answer there.

[t0kneneng]

Originally Posted by phoenix

I've already said that you're modifying the wrong file, go to the second link you posted and read the answer there.

Ok thanks for pointing out... it is ok to change file permission of this file so can edit and append needed config /opt/zimbra/postfix/conf/master.cf? while zimbra mail server is running?

[t0kneneng]

please ignore my last question...

[t0kneneng]

I'm back after reviewing the guide I made it work, here's I get from zimbra log
dkim-filter[19763]: E8A5721E8A68 "DKIM-Signature" header added

When Append milter_protocol = 2 on main.cf zimbra can't received email from external

When I try to remove milter_protocol = 2 I have this error on my log

warning: milter inet:localhost:20209: can’t read SMFIC_DATA reply packet header: Success

[t0kneneng]

Please help... if I set milter_protocol = 2... our mail zimbra can't received mails but domainkeys keys working... but if I remove milter_protocol = 2, then everything works except domain keys not working again....

[phoenix]

Please update your forum profile with the output of the following command (do not post it in this thread):

zmcontrol -v

Originally Posted by t0kneneng

Please help... if I set milter_protocol = 2... our mail zimbra can't received mails but domainkeys keys working... but if I remove milter_protocol = 2, then everything works except domain keys not working again....

You might want to review some of these posts: "cant read SMFIC_DATA reply packet header:" - Yahoo! Search Results

I did also suggest that you use dk-milter as you might find it easier to set-up than dkim-milter, it is your choice.