[SOLVED] Per-User AS/AV Filters (like sieve) - Spam in PoP3 lost?

[uxbod]

Indeed Join the MS mailing list aswell. Plenty of helpful information on there including custom SpamAssassin rules.

[lovelord]

probably I'm out of topic here, but just asking mysel this:

Is I have configured AS/AV to tag messages @ 33% with [SPAM] tag there is no way to keep messages in inbox folder instead moving them into Junk?

Why this question, for the following reason:

If a pop3 client connect to an inbox and receive all message tagged and not-tagged they could filter in local with any filtering solution, but it tagged messages are moved by server into Junk folder they see no messages and also i've wasted time tagging messages that already are moved into Junk...

There is no way to keep tagged messages into inbox folder without disabling AS discard >80/90% ??

[neyz]

Having a front MW + MS scanner seems like a good idea but how would you integrate it with zimbra ? I mean, then the junk and ham folders would not be working for spam learning and this kinda defeats the purpose of the "per user filtering" no ?

Cheers !

[lovelord]

Nothing,

neither going deep through amavis configuration I've found how it works correctly. There is REALLY no way to say "Zimbra, please, if you tag a message as spam in subject, deliver messages into inbox instead moving them to junk!" ?

This is really quiet important becouse a lot of customers have different way to read email and not all understand what a webmail is...

EDIT:

I thought to reversing the problem: probably I can wait that Zimbra do its dirty work with spam, wait for message tagged into junk and find a way to move again messages from junk to inbox in someway ... really don't know how but if it is impossible to do front... what do you think about?

[neyz]

So that basicly means that on top of having no per user control, people checking their mails with POP3 don't have ANY form of control on their spams right ?

Is it possible to have at least a daily mail sent to users with a summary of blocked spam with a way to release it like MS does ?

Cheers !

[lovelord]

Originally Posted by neyz

So that basicly means that on top of having no per user control, people checking their mails with POP3 don't have ANY form of control on their spams right ?

Is it possible to have at least a daily mail sent to users with a summary of blocked spam with a way to release it like MS does ?

Cheers !

That is the problem, and this is really strange that wasn't be scheduled to be solved. Other webmail solutions or collaboration suites like Kolab or Horde do this... asking why ZCS couldn't.

[phoenix]

Originally Posted by lovelord

That is the problem, and this is really strange that wasn't be scheduled to be solved. Other webmail solutions or collaboration suites like Kolab or Horde do this... asking why ZCS couldn't.

Do search bugzilla if you need information about RFEs or bug reports: Search for bugs

[lovelord]

Originally Posted by phoenix

Do search bugzilla if you need information about RFEs or bug reports: Search for bugs

Thx Phoenix,

I hope you can give us some advices while we are voting for these bugzilla reports:

Bug 14469 – Email blocked by Hotmail due to X-SPAM-* Headers Appended (large number of domains with amavis)

Bug 3870 – per user Spam Assassin score

Bug 3864 – Spam Assassin Score vs. Spam Percentage

Bug 7502 – Deactivate SPAM filter for particular users.

Bug 11063 – Need ability to specify just tag but don't kill spam

Bug 14047 – AntiSpam doesn't work with external POP3 Account

Bug 16329 – Need Admin GUI for spam filtering and anti-virus configuration and monitoring

Bug 30506 – Ability to disable antispam/antivirus per domain

[neyz]

Well, i'm supposed to have a chat with sales and technical support later on today to present me the Zimbra network solution. Needless to say this is imperative for us so we will see, maybe it's schedueled for V6 ? ^^

[lovelord]

Originally Posted by neyz

Well, i'm supposed to have a chat with sales and technical support later on today to present me the Zimbra network solution. Needless to say this is imperative for us so we will see, maybe it's schedueled for V6 ? ^^

Zimbra sales support in Italy already contacted me for a personalized solution for our company. We are a little ISP in Tuscany, we cannot hope that offer will be so low in price that we probably accept... so I've to center my attention on ZCS because mailservers must be changed this August in a way or another.